New!
Principles of Opioid Management of Pain -
Joel Hochman and members of NFTP and PRN
listServ; Summer 2006
--
The Project
for Pain and Chemical Dependency:
'Defining What is Right, Not What is Wrong'
Comment (DeLuca):
A consensus document defining medically correct, ethical,
patient-centric, respectful opioid treatment for pain.
Unlike almost every other such effort promulgated by pain societies or
Fed. agencies, Principles does not encourage physicians take on a law
enforcement role, and does not discriminate against high-dose patients or
non-medical drug users in pain.
See also:
'High Dosage' Opioid Management
-
Hochman;
Practical Pain
Management; 2005
Chronic Pain:
I - A New
Disease? ;
II -
The Case for Opiates -
Daniel Brookoff; Hospital Practice;
2000
White Paper on Opioids and Pain: A Pan-European Challenge
- compiled by
OPEN Minds; 2005
|
The Big Chill - Inserting the DEA into End-of-Life Care
- Timothy
E. Quill and Diane E. Meier; New England Journal of
Medicine; 345(1); 1-3; 2006-01-06
--
"A finding in favor of the Justice Dept [in
Gonzalez v. Oregon] would not only nullify the Death
with Dignity Act, permitting the DEA to penalize
physicians for providing medications to hasten
the deaths of terminally ill patients, but also
have a chilling effect on physicians' willingness to
treat patients' terminal symptoms."
See also:
Let's Get Serious About Chronic Pain (PDF)
- Jane Brody; New York Times; 2006-01-10
|
|
Universal
Precautions in Pain Medicine: A Rational Approach to the Treatment of
Chronic Pain
by Gourlay et
al.; Pain Medicine; March 2005
--
"All patients [need to be assessed] in a biopsychosocial model,
including past and present aberrant behaviors... and by applying careful
and reasonably set limits in the clinician patient
relationship, it is possible to triage chronic pain patients into three
categories according to risk.
Comment:
Peer-reviewed journal article
proposing 'universal precautions' be applied to pain patients as
potential addicts - sort of like they had a fatal, highly infectious
disease (which neither pain nor addiction are). This is NOT a
prescription for stigma-reduction, BTW.
It's official: Pain Medicine and Addiction Medicine have 'Jumped the Shark.'
|
|
Opioid Rotation in Patients with Cancer Pain -
Bruera et al.;
Cancer; 78(4); 852-857; 1996 --
"The
dose ratio between morphine and hydromorphone was 5.33... However, the
hydromorphone / methadone ratio was found to be 5 to10 times higher than
expected [given methadone's equipotence with morphine]."
See also:
Opiate Rotation, Incomplete Cross-Tolerance, and Hyperalgesic Metabolites
–
DeLuca; 2001
Psychostimulants as Adjuvant Analgesics
-
Bruera
and Watanabe; J Pain Symptom Manage.; 1994
High-Dose Ketamine in
Neuropathic Pain -
Tarumi
et al.; J Pain Symptom Manage.; 2000
|
|
High-Dose Ketamine in
Neuropathic Pain
-
Tarumi, Y.; Watanabe, S.;
Bruera, E.; Ishitani, K.; Journal of Pain and Symptom
Management; 19(6); 2000. Posted: 2005-12-04
--
"Neuronal hyperactivity is at least partially mediated by
N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) receptors and agonists. Clinical
evidence has reported that NMDA receptor antagonists reduce
pain caused by nerve injury. Ketamine is one of the
commercially available NMDA antagonists. We report a case in
which ketamine was successfully used to treat severe
neuropathic pain."
|
|
Opioids in Pain Management - Henry
McQuay; Lancet; 353; 2229-2232;1999-06-26
--
"Opioids are our most powerful analgesics, but politics,
prejudice, and our continuing ignorance still impede optimum
prescribing... The restriction of opioid availability to
protect society and the individual continues in many
countries. In this review I focus on chronic and cancer
pain, but many of the principles apply in acute pain. The
justification for this focus is that patients with chronic
pain may suffer longer and unnecessarily if we prescribe and
legislate badly."
|
|
Tutorial: The Role of Opioids in Cancer Pain Management -
M. Fukshansky, et al.; Pain Practice, 5(1), 2005
Comment
(DeLuca):
This medical journal tutorial includes a brief
overview of pain syndromes, and reviews the basics of opioid therapy,
opioid pharmacology, opioid rotation, the properties of the individual
opioids, and the management of common side effects of opioids.
See also:
Chronic Pain II – Case for Opiates; Daniel Brookoff; Hospital
Practice; 35(9); 2000
|
|
Emergency Withdrawal:
Pain Meds in the Wake of Katrina -
American Pain Foundation
Alert;
2005-09-04
Comment:
The American Pain Foundation offers this
brief, peer-reviewed and credible
information to
help individuals understand withdrawal symptoms, warnings, and tips
about how to taper medication to lessen or avoid withdrawal.
|
|
White Paper on Opioids and Pain:
A Pan-European Challenge
Compiled by OPEN Minds; 2005-06 --
"The
reputation of opioids has been damaged by a singular 'war on
drugs' emphasis aimed only at their potential for abuse...
[What] is
required... is a straightforward process of updating
the numerous rules and regulations that are identified in this White
Paper."
|
|
Medical Marijuana,
Federalism, and the Supreme Court
by Gostin;
JAMA; 2005; 294(7); 842-844
--
"[M]arijuana may offer respite for some patients—a
position supported by patient experiences and physician opinions. The
"drug war" metaphor does not justify an ideology that removes hope from
patients when they are most vulnerable and in need."
See also:
War on Pain
Sufferers #3: -
Medical MJ
|
|
Characterizations of
Long-term Oxycodone / Acetaminophen Prescriptions in Veterans
by J.A. Hermos et al.; Arch. Internal Med.; 2004
Comment:
They
went looking for abuse and escalating doses, and found mostly stable
patients.
Unfortunately, the authors fail to measure the clinical adequacy or
inadequacy of the opioid therapy provided. The average VA dose for the "long
term management of chronic pain" is apparently four Vicodin daily - a
shockingly LOW dose for anything other than the mildest chronic pain.
|
|
[Top of Page]
|
|
Methadone for Pain States
by
Toombs & Kraal; Amer.Fam.Physician; 4/1/2005 --
"Methadone's unique
pharmacokinetics and pharmacodynamics make it a valuable option in the
management of... chronic pain, including neuropathic pain
states. It may be an appropriate replacement for [other] opioids when side
effects have limited further dosage escalation."
Comment:
Brief but pretty
good review of the pharmacology of methadone and principles of it's use
for the treatment of chronic pain.
|
|
"High
Dosage" Opioid Management - Considerations in Treating Intractable Pain
by J.S.
Hochman, MD, Executive Director
NFTP; Practical Pain Management; March 2005
--
"When
titrated carefully to effectiveness, patients achieve dramatic
improvement in pain levels and function, with no evidence of adverse
effects, medical complications or addiction... Addiction is non-existent
in our most recent series of 204 patients followed for four years."
|
|
The Challenge of Prescription Drug Misuse: A
Review and Commentary
by
William
Hurwitz; Pain Medicine; 6(2); March '05 --
"How
can there be a balanced policy without a scale to measure all the
relevant outcomes?"
|
|
Opioid Use in Orthopedic
Spine Clinic Mahowald et al.; Arthritis &
Rheum.; Jan. 2005 -- This study
provides evidence to support [opioid therapy by] docs treating chronic
musculoskeletal diseases [and protect them] from regulatory agencies. [It]will
benefit patients by [easing access] to these effective, safe
medications. Comment:
Wow; this
could be huge.
|
A New Set of Knees Comes
at a Price: A Whole Lot of Pain
by Jane Brody; New York Times; 2/8/2005 --
"I learned much later that I could have been prescribed a much higher dose of
narcotics with no ill effect and much better pain control. No doctor I reported
to, however, including the surgeon, even considered that."
|
Opioid Rotation in Patients with Cancer Pain -
Bruera et al.;
Cancer; 78(4); 852-857; 1996
--
"The
dose ratio between morphine and hydromorphone was 5.33... However, the
hydromorphone / methadone ratio was found to be 5 to10 times higher than
expected [given methadone's equipotence with morphine]."
See also:
Opiate Rotation, Incomplete Cross-Tolerance, and Hyperalgesic Metabolites
–
DeLuca; 2001
Psychostimulants as Adjuvant Analgesics
-
Bruera
and Watanabe; J Pain Symptom Manage.; 1994
New! -
High-Dose Ketamine in
Neuropathic Pain -
Tarumi
et al.; J Pain Symptom Manage.; 2000
|
|
High-Dose Ketamine in
Neuropathic Pain
-
Tarumi, Y.; Watanabe, S.;
Bruera, E.; Ishitani, K.; Journal of Pain and Symptom
Management; 19(6); 2000. Posted: 2005-12-04
--
"Neuronal hyperactivity is at least partially mediated by
N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) receptors and agonists. Clinical
evidence has reported that NMDA receptor antagonists reduce
pain caused by nerve injury. Ketamine is one of the
commercially available NMDA antagonists. We report a case in
which ketamine was successfully used to treat severe
neuropathic pain."
|
|
Opioids in Pain Management - Henry
McQuay; Lancet; 353; 2229-2232;1999-06-26 --
"Opioids are our most powerful analgesics, but politics,
prejudice, and our continuing ignorance still impede optimum
prescribing... The restriction of opioid availability to
protect society and the individual continues in many
countries. In this review I focus on chronic and cancer
pain, but many of the principles apply in acute pain. The
justification for this focus is that patients with chronic
pain may suffer longer and unnecessarily if we prescribe and
legislate badly."
|
|
Chronic
Pain:
Part 1. A New Disease?
Part 2. The Case for Opiates by Daniel Brookoff; Hospital Practice; 2000.
-- "If a patient's physical pain has prevented him or her
from living life fully, using a medication that allows a
return to normal activities cannot be called drug abuse."
--
Compare and contrast to the
article by Ballantyne (directly below). Brookoff
is accurate, thorough, and lacks the creepy, vapid feeling
of Ballantyne's work. This is a far better Review, IMO.
..alex...
|
|
Opioid
Therapy for Chronic Pain
by Ballantyne & Mao; NEJM; 11/13/2003.
I disagree with many of the conclusions and implications that
arise from this review, for example, the concept of
a "ceiling" dose limit. But this is an important article
even though I find it perpetuates traditional, wrongheaded, WOD
thinking.
..alex...
|
|
Lost
Productive Time & Cost Due to Common Pain Conditions in the
US
by Walter Stewart, et. al., JAMA,
11/12/2003.
"Conclusion: Pain is inordinately
common and disabling... Most pain-related lost productive
time occurs... as reduced performance."
|
|
Race,
Ethnicity, & Pain Treatment -
by Vence Bonham; J. Law, Med. & Ethics,
2001. "Racial and
ethnic minorities are at higher risk for the ineffective
treatment of pain. While others have investigated racial and
ethnic disparities in access to health services generally,
Bonham presents the first comprehensive review of the
literature on racial and ethnic disparities in the treatment
of pain."
|
|
Pain Management and Provider Liability: No More Excuses
- by Barry Furrow; J.
Law, Med. & Ethics, 2001. "Pain is undertreated in the
American health-care system at all levels: physician offices,
hospitals, longterm facilities. The result is needless
suffering for patients, complications that cause further
injury or death, and the added costs in treatment overall. ...
Excuses for shortcomings are simply not acceptable any
longer."
|
|
Interpretation
of "Aberrant" Drug-Related Behaviors
[PDF] -
by Frank B. Fisher, M.D., J.Amer.Physicians &
Surg. 2004. -- Excellent examination,
by a guy who has really been there, of the crucial
"Doctors
Dilemma"- the impossibility of distinguishing the
“deserving” chronic pain patient from the presumably
undeserving drug addict.
..alex...
|
|
Mixed
Message on Prescription Drug Abuse.
by Brian Vastag; JAMA, 2001.--
"The most egregious underprescribing occurred
with idiopathic back pain, the most common kind. While the
expert panel recommended that virtually all patients with
such pain-and who do not respond to other treatments-be
given an opioid analgesic, only 20% of physicians said they
would actually write that prescription. "
|
|
Pain
Patients and Docs Now Causalities of War on Drugs -
Yearbook of Experts, Authorities and
Spokespersons, June 30, 2004. --
"'The war on drugs has turned into a war
on doctors and the legal drugs they prescribe and on
the suffering patients who need the drugs to attempt
anything approaching a normal life," said Kathryn Serkes, of
the AAPS...
Assistant U.S. Attorney Gene Rossi declared
to a reporter that 'our office will try our best to root out
[certain doctors] like the Taliban. Stay tuned.'"
|
Pain
Without Treatment,
Wrong Without Remedy by William Hurwitz, M.D., 1992.
--
"This [paper] argues that
pain patients are protected as persons with
disabilities entitled to appropriate medical treatment and
that the regulatory scheme, through its disparate impact on
their access to such treatment, violates the law."
|
|
[Top of Page]
|
Amphetamines
and Analgesia - I.D.M.U.; British National
Formulary 35 (March 1998) p186
|
The
Role of Psychostimulants in Patients with Cancer Pain
by Bruera; 1995.
|
Potentiation
of opioid analgesia by psychostimulant drugs: a review
- by Dalal; Pain Symptom Manage 1998 Oct; 16(4):
245-53 (Abstract)
|
Chronic
Pain In America: Roadblocks To Relief by Rovine; 1999;
From the American
Pain Society
|
Defining
Key Terms in Pain Management - Purdue Pharma
|
|
Chronic
Pain: Treatment Barriers and Strategies for Clinical Practice
by Glajchen; 2001; Journal of Amer. Board of
Family Practice, 14(3):178-183. (Abstract & Introduction)
|
Recognizing
preventing and medication diversion. by Cole;
2001; Fam.Pract.Manag.,
Vol. 8, No. 2, pp 37-41
|
How
Pain is Under Treated in the US by
Skip Baker;
From the American
Society for Action on Pain
|
Management
of Chronic Non-Cancer Pain: A Guide to Appropriate Use of Opioids by
Schneider; 1998; Journal
of Care Management
|
Opiate
Rotation and Hyperalgesic Metabolites
by DeLuca, 2001.
|
Opioid
Therapy for Chronic Nonmalignant Pain: Clinicians'
Perspective by
Russell K. Portenoy.
Journal of Law,
Medicine & Ethics, 24(4): 296-309; 1996.
|
The
OxyContin Controversy (Common Sense for Drug
Policy ) - circa June, 2001.
|
New
form of OxyContin would thwart abusers by
Rubin, USA Today; 8/13/2001.
|
The
truth about oxycontin from a medical point of view
by DeLuca; 8/8/2001.
|
Pain
Specialists and Addiction Medicine Specialists Unite to
Address Critical Issues - by Portenoy;
APS
Bull.; 9(2); April 1999.
|
When
Not Treating Pain Equals Abuse - With a hefty
verdict, California jury sends hospitals a message about relieving
patients agony. by Greene; 2001; Health
and Hospital News, October 2001, pp 34. Ms.
Lee, president of the Compassion In Dying Federation is quoted: "The
entire medical community is now on notice about the seriousness of
the undertreatment of pain, [t]his is medical education by jury
trial."
|
|
|